Also,graphicsand
producedpublic service announcements
are still available on this page for webcasters to use to
encourage listeners to support HR 5469.
From Friday's midday edition... BY KURT HANSON The
best hope for a thriving Internet radio industry which
would be good for consumers, broadcasters, webcasters, artists,
and even (although they may not be willing to publicly acknowledge
it) record labels is the bill that Rep.
James Sensenbrenner (R-WI, pictured at left), chairman
of the House Judiciary Committee, introduced yesterday (see story
below).
Because both webcasters and copyright
owners are dissatisfied with the rate decision and have filed
appeals in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, Sensenbrenner's bill
would suspend the deadline for CARP royalty
payments by six months, "providing both sides the
opportunity to have their day in court," he notes.
Without the passage of his bill, he observes, the industry
could become extinct before
the appeals have the chance to be heard in court! Broadcasters will
quit streaming, small webcasters will go bankrupt, and niche artists
will lose any chance of exposure of their music to the public.
How you can help: Because this bill is scheduled to come to the House floor
for a vote on Tuesday, the time to show your support of this bill
is today!
(1)
Identify your Congressman Look up the phone number
of the Washington, DC office of your representative in the House
of Representatives via the Congress.org website here:
(A) Type your ZIP code into the first box on the page. (B) If
necessary, use the form at the bottom of the next page to find
your nine-digit ZIP code. (C) Under the photo of your "Rep.,"
click the "info"
link.
(2) Call and ask for
the right person Ask to speak with "the legislative
aide in charge of Internet and copyright issues."
Learn his or her name. Explain that you're a constituent
i.e., you live or work in the Congressman's district.
(3) Ask for their support "I'm calling to urge you to support HR
5469 next week the bill that would prevent Internet
radio from being shut down
on October 20th. (It will be up for a vote on Tuesday.) As you
probably know, the CARP process was a total failure. Both
copyright owners and webcasters are unhappy with the
decision. This bill would postpone the CARP decision for six months
so that both sides can have
time to have their appeals heard in the Court of Appeals."
(4) Add personal insight Talk about how the CARP decision affects you
as a small businessperson and/or a listener. Mention the great
Internet radio stations we've already lost (Entercom
stations, smaller-market Clear Channel stations, SOMA FM, free
KPIG, etc.).Mention the new artists
you've discovered and the CDs
you've purchased thanks to Internet radio. And make sure they
understand the difference
between Internet radio and peer-to-peer download services like
Napster they're totally different! ("Napster bad (maybe)!
Internet radio good!")
(5) Ask for a commitment Offer to leave your number if they have any questions.
If they're noncommittal, ask if you can call back on Monday to
see what they've decided. In the unlikely event that your Congressman's
aide is unfamiliar with the bill or needs a copy, feel free to
point them here (or simply download the Adobe Acrobat file yourself
and e-mail it to them):
If time permits, you could repeat this
process for the Congressman from the district in which
you work, from the district in
which you grew up (especially if, say, your parents live there and
are voters), from a district in which you know you have listeners,
etc.
Now
send a fax, too! Another way to communicate your message is to use the automated
fax system Lightningcast has
prepared: http://www.broadcastpromotions.net/carp/hr5469/.
One simply needs to supply one's name, address, and nine-digit ZIP
code, and a "personalized" fax with all the relevant information
is sent to the appropriate Congressman.
If you're a webcaster or broadcaster, you should also ask
your listeners to help. Please scroll down to find banner
ads and PSAs (or links to such) near the bottom of today's issue.
And we've revised the home page of SaveInternetRadio.org.
Finally, let us know how you're doing! Drop us a line to
feedback@kurthanson.com
or use the feedback form lower on this page. Thanks!
...
... Obvious question: Will artists suffer
from this proposed six-month delay? The answer is, essentially,
no.
Let's do the math: Total Internet radio listening this
month is roughly 40 million hours. At the midpoint of the period
during which retroactive royalties are due, it might have been
20 million hours. Multiplied by four years, that's about 1 billion
hours of listening or about 15 billion
"performances." At $.0007/performance (ignoring
the fact that some webcasters owe the lower noncommercial rate),
that's $10.5 million. I would guess 1/3 of that will be uncollectable
(because the webcasters would be bankrupted by the CARP decision),
leaving $7 million. Half of that is supposed to go to artists,
or $3.5 million, less SoundExchange
administration costs.
I would estimate that about 1/3 of Internet radio airplay
goes to the 500 or so successful, big-name
artists (e.g., Britney Spears, the Rolling Stones,
Coldplay, etc.) who have million-selling albums and other revenue
streams and for whom a delay in receiving a check for $2,333
less SoundExchange administrative costs would not be a major
hardship.
More importantly, the balance would be divided up among
the 10,000 or so other artists who get airplay on Internet radio
and for whom SoundExchange administers royalties. The average
one-time-only check would be $233
less SoundExchange administrative costs, representing royalties
of about $4.86/month for
48 months.
Yes, it would be a shame if a delay in receiving this
one-time $233-less-adminstrative-costs check hurts these artists,
but there are two points to consider: (1) This is happening
because their interests are not being
well-represented in the record industry's negotiations
with webcasters. There were months
of negotiations that could have led to a compromise royalty
agreement for small webcasters; the continued failure of those
negotiations is what led to this bill. (2) If I were
an artist that wasn't getting
significant AM or FM airplay but was
getting exposure on Internet radio, I know I'd be willing to
postpone the receipt of that $233-less-adminstrative-costs check
if I knew that the tradeoff for receiving that check was that
outlets for my music were going to be bankrupted and shut down.
-- KH ...
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Various
professionals from the Internet radio industry are contributing
their talent and efforts to build a storehouse of resources to support
Rep. Sensenbrenner's "Relief
for Small-Business Webcasters" bill. These various graphic
and audio files are intended to be shared by the industry, and used
by anyone who'd like to encourage support of the bill.
Here are a "banner" and a "tile" for use
on your site (courtesy of IRH-Live's
Rabbett). He links them to
his info page here, but the text on the images is such that they could
link to any info page (such as SaveInternetRadio.org).
Note the copy on the graphics, as some are time-sensitive (i.e.
only meant for today).
This banner is from the Web Angel:
Rabbett has also produced a series of "time sensitive"
PSAs. You can download them from his page here.
The voice of iM Networks
and "Best of Planet" programmer
Bone Mama (above right) has voiced a 60-second, 128
kbps MP3 public service announcement (PSA), available here.
If you are a graphic artist, voice talent, producer, etc.,
and would like to contribute your work to the effort, please let
us know about it so we can link to it. Send e-mail to paul@kurthanson.com.
We'd love to be able to share it. Thanks!
According to a published report, some key Democrats in the
House of Representatives may fight HR 5469, the bill introduced
to
postpone royalties for Internet radio, when it comes to a vote tomorrow.
Rep. John Conyers (D-MI), the House Judiciary Committee's
senior Democrat, is reportedly angry that he wasn't informed that
the bill would be introduced, and that it will be voted on in without
a hearing. The bill was introduced by the committee's chairman,
Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-WI).
Democratic leadership will reportedly ask Republican leaders
to keep the bill off the "suspension calendar," according to the
report, published by the Hollywood Reporter.
Tomorrow's vote will take place during what's called a "suspension
session." The House rules are temporarily suspended to expedite
the process. Measures passed in suspension sessions require a two-thirds
(as opposed to a simple) majority of votes.
Today is the deadline for music copyright owners and webcasters
to submit proposals to the Copyright Office on recordkeeping
data formats for webcasting.
On September 17, the U.S.
Copyright Office, in the Federal Register, solicited guidance
from the involved parties on the "electronic format in which
recordkeeping data must be maintained" and "the method(s)
for delivery of the data" to SoundExchange (See RAINhere).
SoundExchange is the division of the RIAA that was officially
designated as the "receiving agent" for webcast royalty
fees.
Details for those wishing to submit proposals can be found
(in Adobe Acrobat format) here.
From ABCNews.com: "Rep. Patsy
Mink, a fierce liberal who co-authored landmark gender
equity legislation and had been
expected to easily defeat her GOP opponent in the November general
election, died Saturday. She was 74.
"The Hawaii Democrat died at Straub Clinic and Hospital,
where she had been treated since Aug. 30 for viral pneumonia stemming
from chickenpox, said her spokesman, Andy Winer...
"Mink had been a member of the House for 24 years over
two different stretches. She won re-election two years ago by a
nearly two-to-one margin, and had been considered a sure winner
in this year's race against Republican state Rep. Bob McDermott."
Representative Mink was one of the earliest supporters for
Internet radio since the CARP determination was announced in February.
In March she wrote to the Library of Congress in protest of the
CARP decision (see RAINhere),
and she was an original cosponsor of Rep. Jay Inslee's Internet
Radio Fairness Act.
"I
emphasized my stake in (Net radio) as an 'independent-label'
musician..."
Wanted to let you know: I reached an aide in LaHood' local
office (Peoria, IL) to explain in detail why the bill should be passed.
I emphasized both my devotion to Internet radio as a listener, and
also my stake in it as an "independent-label" musician needing noncommercial
airplay.
Aide Jamie was offering to take down a comment card that will
be given to the Rep., as he is in the local district today. I believe
she understood the basic points and had noted them for me. I also
offered to make myself available to an aide to explain these issues,
and to represent the position of independent musician needing more
appropriate royalty rates than those in the CARP rec.
I forwarded your e-mail to the list-serv for KDHX-FM radio,
St. Louis, MO, in hoped that programmers (DJs) and listeners will
join me on the HR 5469 band wagon. I will call LaHood's office Monday
afternoon if I haven't heard back from them on the Rep's position,
to find out if he will vote YES. Keep up the good work, and I'll do
what I can.
Frank Trompeter
"A
blatant stomp upon our freedom of expression..."
Today I emailed Rep Riley Alabama 3rd District in support of
HR5469. I hope it helps.
I am an American living in Germany and Alabama is my home
of record. Please don't hold it against me. :-) I met my wife there
and abruptly went for greener shores. I came from a military family
and served in the service for 12 years. Now I am a defense contractor
supporting out men and women in uniform.
The CARP and DMCA really ground on my nerves as a blatant stomp
upon our freedom of expression/speech. Internet Radio has given me
the chance to hear music, news and commentary that would have been
otherwise unavailable to me. If there is anything else we can do to
help drop me an e-mail.
Viva Internet Radio!
Regards, David H. Gagne
"He'd
been 'tied up on the phone all day'.."
It's going to be interesting indeed to see what happens with
HR 5469 The way it's being fast-tracked, and with Congress, to say
the least, having other things on its mind, many of the members won't
have had much time for exposure to lobbying either for or against
it.
My Representative, Jim McDermott, is presently in Iraq, and
won't be back until Tuesday morning. I'm sure that his neighbor Jay
Inslee will do his best to fill him in (grin!). But it was rather
interesting that I didn't have a chance to talk with the "legislative
aide in charge of Internet and copyright issues" because he'd been
"tied up on the phone all day".
Art Marriott
"Thanks
for the information..."
I LOVE Internet Radio -- THANKS for the information on your
website.
I have phoned DC today and urged the support for HR5469 of
the Representatives in the following districts:
-- my home (Dan Miller, Sarasota, FL)
-- my office (Jim Davis, Tampa, FL)
-- my old address (Judy Bigggert, Westmont, IL)
Thanks for your support.
Jim Fasetti
"My
comments would be passed along..."
I personally called my Congressional rep today and spoke
with an aide about support for HR 5469. Being a recently introduced
bill, the aide was not clear on what the Congresswoman's position
is at this time, but my comments would be passed along to her (Rep.
Juanita Millender-McDonald (D-CA 37th).
Roger Holman
... Here is a growing list of webcasters
who, because they don't feel they can manage webcasting royalties
in a viable business, have decided that it's in their best interests
to silence their streams. (We thank them for their hard work
and dedication to their audiences and the industry, and wish
them luck in their future endeavors...)
Have
we missed others? Use the feedback form above or e-mail
us here.
Other public
stations now off line
This is from the SOS:
Save Our Streams website, which focuses the struggle
against thewebcasting royalty rates as they pertain to independent
educational and noncommercial stations.