Daily news and commentary on the key issues involving radio and the Internet    
     

About us
Welcome!
Contact RAIN
Feedback form

Coherent Design

Archives
Past issues
Site reviews
Guest essay
Metrics analysis

Resources
Copyright Law
DMCA

Metrics
Arbitron
   Channels
   Networks
MeasureCast
   Weekly
   Monthly

Click here to make RAIN your default homepage!


We'll send you a brief daily summary of each day's stories with a clickable link to the RAIN home page.

 

 

RAIN exclusive analysis
CARP arbitrators gave RIAA more than they asked for!
BY KURT HANSON
In looking back on old press clippings
of the initial negotiations between Webcasters and the RIAA two years ago (and of course when I say "press clippings," I mean a Google search), I came across a striking finding:

The initial debate between the two sides was regarding the RIAA's request from certain Webcasters for a license fee equivalent to 15% of gross revenues, which Webcasters characterized as a "much higher than fair" amount. DiMA Executive Director Jonathan Potter (below) was quoted at the time as saying, "DiMA members' position on that has been, 'Thank you very much, we'll see you at arbitration" (See Wired News article here).

As it turns out, last week's arbitration recommendation was in the form of a per-song-streamed fee ($.0014 per song per listener, or about 2¢/hour for a 15-song hour) rather than in a percentage of revenues. However, translated into a percentage of revenues, the arbitrator's decision seems to give the record companies significantly MORE than they were initially asking for!

Let's do the math: Broadcast radio is a $20 billion per year business. America's roughly 200 million listeners (age 12+) listen about 20 hours a week each to radio, on average, according to Arbitron, suggesting that broadcast radio gets about 4 billion hours per week of listening -- or a little more than 200 billion hours a year.

Divide 200 billion hours of listening by $20 billion in revenues, and you'll calculate that broadcast radio's gross revenues seem to be roughly 10¢/listener-hour.

Double-check:
This figure is consistent with a broadcast radio station running nine spots at average local/national spot rates of a $10 CPM (i.e., /impression) and five spots at network rates of a $2 CPM (i.e., 1/5 of a cent per impression). The math seems to check out.

Realize that in today's advertising environment, Webcasters are seeing revenues per listener-hour that are much, much lower than broadcast radio's. Nonetheless, let's make the optimistic assumption that Webcasters could eventually see the same kind of revenues that terrestrial broadcasters are seeing. (Although that seems unlikely given the lack of FCC-imposed scarcity and the lower number of spots per hour that Webcasting will hopefully offer listeners.)

Making that optimistic assumption, the arbitrators' recommendation would be for RIAA license fees that are the equivalent of 20% of gross revenues! (Note that that's 33% more than the RIAA was originally asking for.) (RIAA President/CEO Hilary Rosen is pictured left.)

Worse yet, we imagine that there are very few Webcasters, if any, who have seen even 2¢/listener-hour in advertising revenues to date. According to the CARP recommendation, these Webcasters would owe sound recording license fees, retroactive to 1998, of more than 100% of gross revenues!

As noted previously in RAIN,
representatives from both sides can continue to press the Copyright Office for proposal changes for 54 more days.

 


Have an opinion? Drop us a note! (Or, to use your own e-mail software, click here.)

  Your e-mail address:
  Your name (if not obvious from your e-mail address):
    Kurt, this is deep background -- don't quote me!

        Thanks!

 

EU may impose a tax on webcasts to Europe from non-EU countries
From ZDNet UK: "The Treasury Department on Wednesday reacted negatively to a European Union move to require non-EU companies to impose a tax on products delivered online to consumers, such as downloaded software or music...

"On Wednesday, the EU Council of economic and finance ministers gave its approval to a European Commission proposal on applying the value-added tax, or VAT, to so-called digital products. Those products could include computer games and software, as well as radio or television broadcasting, delivered online.

"The rule will, for the first time, require non-EU businesses selling products to EU consumers over the Internet to levy the VAT tax on purchases. The EU argues that will put non-EU companies on a level playing field with EU businesses that are required to charge a VAT tax...

"Late last week, the Treasury warned the EU it did not agree with the idea. In a statement, Deputy Treasury Secretary Ken Dam said the Bush administration had "serious concerns" about the idea and hinted it could take the issue up with the World Trade Organisation."

Read the complete article here.

 

We'll send you a brief daily summary of each day's stories with a clickable link to the RAIN home page.
 

MeasureCast, Nielsen advocate streaming media to advertisers
MeasureCast and Nielsen Media Research
have announced that representatives from the two companies will participate in a joint "road show" to tout the benefits of streaming advertising to ad agencies across the country.

In a joint press release yesterday, the two media audience measurement companies revealed their plans to meet with media directors and planning and research executives beginning March 5 in Los Angeles.

Last month, in
a RAIN feature story (here), we reported that Loudeye VP/Sales Ed Bruno had embarked on a similar sales blitz -- and like Hiwire's Bob Nagengast, Lightningcast's Bill Jaris, and Live 365's Ron Denman -- would "evangelize" for the medium. Look for a follow-up to that story in RAIN soon.

In the press release
, MeasureCast CEO Ed Hardy said, "We want to make sure that ad industry executives responsible for making recommendations to their clients include streaming media advertising in their media planning mix. With the aggregation of multiple stations, the streaming audience is becoming large enough to be included in mass media ad buys."

The trip also has planned stops in Chicago, Minneapolis, and New York. MeasureCast has a strategic partnership with Nielsen Media Research and NetRatings to market its products.


Reader feedback
"Makes us eat what we're fed..."

Let's face the bald truth. The Music Industry WANTS to drive everyone else out of the Internet radio business. Internet radio is the future; they intend to control it. And they have the money and the lobbyists to do just that.

Internet radio is clearly the future. Clearly people like it. And clearly, advertisers eventually must show up where listeners spend their time.

So when the copyright office caves in to the music industry and their money and their lobbyists, the future of internet radio is a series of Muzak sites. Innovation will proceed as slowly and fitfully, analagous to the lack of innovation and choice their version of Napster is providing. RAIN will be reduced to commenting on the various flavors of vanilla as the industry makes us eat what we're fed.

On top of that, the fees the Music Industry will pay themselves for broadcasting on stations they control, they will make the artists pay them as part of the promotional costs scam they have used for decades to defraud artists of their pay. (Ask Winston Groom, author of Forrest Gump, confronted with the amazing fact that his royalties from the film, when it had grossed $329 million, had thus far amounted to $0, as the movie had still not made a profit, according to the legendary Hollywood accountants and their own fictions.)

If anyone cares, the CARP ruling is exactly the type of monopolistic behavior Federal Judge Marilyn Hall Patel was talking about in her February 22nd Napster ruling.

  Steve Follmer


"This truly bad law..."

I urge everyone who reads RAIN to go to the website www.anti-DMCA.org for more information about the depth of this truly bad law, and to become actively involved in changing the DMCA to allow webcasters the same freedoms that Terrestrial broadcasters have always had.

  Michael-Leonard Creditor, Coordinator of Programming
World Music Webcast


"Very shortsighted..."

Traditional radio broadcasters should pick their battles more carefully. Using the Internet to stream their terrestrial signal is very shortsighted. Radio's interactive assets can be used MUCH more effectively and profitably by offering clients "cross-platform programs" (advertising packages that combine Spot and Web/database together).

Get off the streaming issue already! Radio should start worrying about realistic revenue producing uses of the Web.

  Mel Taylor


  Feb. 27-Mar. 3, 2002 Canadian Music Week 2002: Toronto, Ont., CA
Mar. 1-3, 2002 ConXis: Conference and Expo for Internet Streaming: Rosemont, IL
  Mar. 14, 2002 16th Annual Bayliss Radio Roast: New York, NY
  Apr. 5-8, 2002 Broadcast Education Association 2002: Las Vegas, NV
  Apr. 6-11, 2002 NAB 2002: Las Vegas, NV
  Apr. 23-26, 2002 Streaming Media West 2002: Los Angeles, CA
 
Are you in or out?
RAIN Vendor Guide (January 2002)
If you'd like to look for a law firm, e-commerce partner, research firm, or NTR revenue opportunity, click here to revisit last week's special "RAIN Vendor Guide" issue!

Ad insertion
Audio processing
Automation systems
Banner ad management

Conferences
Consultants
Content providers
Custom music channels
Custom talk channels
Design firms

Domain name registrars
E-commerce partners
E-mail management
Full-service providers
Internet radio devices
Law firms

Loyalty programs
Networks/Portals
NTR revenue opportunities
PR firms
Production elements

Promotion (artists & records)
Publications

Rep firms
Research and ratings
Sales consulting
Spot sales
Streaming audio formats
Streaming audio software
Streaming providers
Streaming quality metrics
Website design and maintenance
Website features


(Note: If you are a vendor and would like to purchase a listing in this guide, please call us at 1-312-527-3879 or send an e-mail here.)
 

 

Search RAIN

(Hint: Use quotes)
Advanced Search



Click Here for RAIN Radio!


Publications
R&R
RBR
Radio Ink
All Access
Inside Radio
   

Internet Pubs.
Red Herring
Business 2.0
   
Other Publications
(was eRadio)
(Taz Media)
FMQB
   

Software for RAIN's daily e-mail reminders provided by:

 



 
 

TOP

Copyright 2003, RAIN Publications, Inc. All rights reserved.
All logos and trademarks are property of their respective owners.

Your RAIN staff
Kurt Hanson
Publisher
Paul Maloney
Editor
Ralph Sledge
"Site of the Day" Editor
David Don
Developer
Brad Knutson
Intern
Ben Huh
Project Manager